Context-

On August 28, scientists from the LUX-ZEPLIN (LZ) experiment, which operates 1.5 km beneath the earth's surface at the Sanford Underground Research Facility in South Dakota, made a significant announcement. The LZ team, consisting of 200 researchers, had placed the most stringent restrictions yet on the potential identities of dark matter particles. However, the result was not a revelation of what dark matter is but rather what it isn’t. Despite decades of research, these experiments continue to produce null results, leading to a sense of resignation within the scientific community.

The Elusive Nature of Dark Matter

This ongoing struggle highlights the challenge of dark matter research. Various experiments around the world, such as XENON-nT in Italy and PandaX-4T in China, have been attempting to detect dark matter for decades, only to turn up empty-handed. The question remains: what exactly is dark matter, and why is it so difficult to detect?

The Mystery of Dark Matter

What is Dark Matter?

Dark matter is the invisible substance that constitutes the bulk of the universe’s mass. It is responsible for shaping the cosmos as we see it today. In contrast, stars, planets, and gas contribute only 15% of the universe’s mass. The rest is thought to be dark matter, whose nature remains unknown.

The leading hypothesis is that dark matter consists of a type of particle that does not interact with photons (light particles) and has existed since the beginning of the universe, approximately 14 billion years ago. Unlike most particles, dark matter does not disintegrate, and it exerts gravitational forces, which explain its influence on the large-scale structure of the universe.

The Question of Interaction

A central question in dark matter research is whether dark matter interacts with ordinary matter. Specifically, can dark matter particles interact with atomic nuclei and electrons when they come close? Many theories propose that dark matter could “scatter” off visible matter, meaning it could collide with and be deflected by atomic nuclei. The problem is how to detect this interaction, which is incredibly rare and weak.

The Goodman-Witten Proposal: A New Strategy

A Sail to Catch the Wind

In 1985, physicists Mark Goodman and Ed Witten proposed a new approach to detect dark matter, an idea that has since inspired a subfield of experimental physics. The Goodman-Witten (GW) proposal was to detect dark matter particles by setting up a detector deep underground to shield it from cosmic radiation. The detector would act like a sail trying to catch the wind: if a dark matter particle collided with a nucleus in the detector, the nucleus would recoil, and scientists could measure this recoil as evidence of dark matter.

This method was a reversal of traditional experiments, such as Ernest Rutherford’s gold foil experiment. In Rutherford’s setup, scientists fired a beam of known particles at a target and measured the deflections. In the Goodman-Witten proposal, the "beam" is the dark matter particles, which are unknown, and the target is a well-understood metal placed underground.

The goal of the experiment was to measure two unknown quantities: the mass of the dark matter particle and the rate at which dark matter scatters off atomic nuclei. Physicists use a parameter called the cross-section to quantify this scattering rate.

Measuring the Cross-section: Tracking Dark Matter

Understanding the Cross-section

The concept of the cross-section is essential for understanding particle interactions. Consider how light behaves in different materials. In a vacuum, a photon travels without interference; in glass, it may scatter after traveling some distance; in a rock, it is quickly absorbed. These scenarios represent different cross-sections: zero, small, and large, respectively.

The same idea applies to dark matter: researchers want to measure how likely dark matter particles are to scatter off atomic nuclei. In the original Goodman-Witten proposal, the goal was to measure a cross-section as small as 10^-38 cm², an astonishingly tiny value. This would mean that dark matter particles could travel through 10 billion kilometres of rock before interacting with anything.

The LUX-ZEPLIN Experiment and Dark Matter Detection

Advances in Dark Matter Detection

Since the Goodman-Witten proposal, dark matter detection experiments have grown dramatically in size and sophistication. Modern experiments like LUX-ZEPLIN expose large quantities of liquid xenon or argon to dark matter particles for years at a time, improving their ability to detect weaker interactions. As a result, scientists have been able to rule out dark matter-nucleus cross-sections as small as 10^-44 cm², a million times smaller than the original Goodman-Witten limit.

This was the achievement announced by the LUX-ZEPLIN experiment in August: they had set the tightest limits yet on the possible cross-section of dark matter. While this result did not confirm the identity of dark matter, it significantly narrowed down the possibilities.

The Neutrino Fog

However, there is a limit to how far this method can go. Future detectors, which will weigh tens to hundreds of tonnes, will encounter increasing amounts of noise from neutrinos, ghostly particles produced in the Sun’s core and the Earth’s atmosphere. These neutrinos can mimic the signals of dark matter particles, making it difficult to tell them apart.

The “neutrino fog” is a significant obstacle for future dark matter research. It refers to the point at which neutrino interactions will dominate the signals detected by underground experiments, obscuring potential dark matter signals. This was part of the reason for the sense of resignation following LUX-ZEPLIN’s announcement: researchers had hoped to discover dark matter before they hit this neutrino limit.

Other Approaches

New Avenues of Research

While experiments like LUX-ZEPLIN focus on detecting dark matter that interacts with atomic nuclei, scientists are also pursuing other strategies. One promising approach is to search for lighter dark matter particles that are less likely to scatter off heavy atomic nuclei. Detecting these particles requires more sensitive detectors capable of picking up smaller energy transfers.

For example, picture a small bug colliding with a massive truck. The truck barely moves, but with the right tools, you might be able to detect the tiny energy transfer from the collision. Similarly, physicists are developing new technologies that can detect these faint signals.

Special Materials and Advanced Technologies

Detecting lighter dark matter requires detectors made from special materials, some of which are currently being explored in the field of condensed matter physics. These materials are extremely sensitive to small energy transfers and could offer a new way to detect elusive dark particles.

The pursuit of dark matter unites researchers across multiple disciplines, from particle physics to condensed matter physics, reflecting the interdisciplinary nature of modern scientific exploration.

Conclusion

The quest to identify dark matter remains one of the most significant challenges in modern physics. While experiments like LUX-ZEPLIN have made tremendous progress in narrowing down the possibilities, the identity of dark matter continues to elude scientists. The detection of dark matter would revolutionize our understanding of the universe, shedding light on the invisible substance that makes up the vast majority of its mass.

As researchers continue to push the limits of detection technology, they are also facing new challenges, such as the neutrino fog, which threatens to obscure dark matter signals in future experiments. Nevertheless, scientists are exploring new approaches, including the search for lighter dark matter particles and the development of more sensitive detectors.

The hunt for dark matter, much like other great quests in the history of science, demands the full ingenuity and creativity of the scientific community. The discovery of dark matter, whenever it comes, will not only answer fundamental questions about the universe but also mark the culmination of decades of perseverance, innovation, and collaboration.

Source- The Hindu